The Harari Question: Humanity's Stories
————
If there is a rock-star historian alive today, it is Yuval Noah Harari. Since Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind was published in 2012 and translated into more than sixty languages, "told stories put our species on top" has become the headline reading of history. The books that followed — Homo Deus, 21 Lessons for the 21st Century, and the 2024 volume Nexus: A Brief History of Information Networks from the Stone Age to AI — completed a tetralogy that has stayed on the bestseller lists for more than a decade.
With these four books, Harari pushed a single question to its extreme: how did humanity get here, and what will carry us on from here?
The division of labor among the four runs roughly like this: Sapiens looks backward, on how Homo sapiens climbed to the top of the food chain with "fictive stories"; Homo Deus looks forward, on how the old stories fail once algorithms know you better than you know yourself; 21 Lessons turns to the present, taking twenty-one letters one by one through the现实 predicaments of a technological upheaval; and Nexus traces the evolution of information networks themselves, from the Stone Age to artificial intelligence.
I do not agree with Harari's defining information as "story" — story is only one form that information takes in human networks — but I do agree with his account of what stories do.
That is an insight, and from it I see two problems: one grand, one small.
Just as the question raised by Joseph Needham has been named "Needham's Question," and the one raised by Qian Xuesen "Qian Xuesen's Question," I name these two the "Harari Question." That gives our analysis a target, and gives everyone something concrete to discuss.
I. The Story Harari Tells
Some 70,000 years ago, the ancestors of Homo sapiens went through a cognitive revolution. In muscle we are no match for the Neanderthals; in raw individual intelligence, we were about neck and neck. But today it is we who stand at the top of the food chain. On what grounds?
Harari's answer: on stories.
A solitary human can, at best, manage a band of about a hundred — no essential difference from a chimpanzee. Yet humans accomplished something no other animal ever has: setting millions, even hundreds of millions of strangers pulling in the same direction. What connects them? Not blood, not scent — Harari says: stories.
One story can be believed by ten million people at once, and the scale of cooperation among those ten million is empire, papacy, company, currency… Rome was not built by its legions; the legion itself was a story: why would a farmer bleed for an emperor he had never met? Because he believed he belonged to "Rome." Money is also a story: why does a piece of paper buy a sheep? Because everyone believes that everyone else believes in that paper. Nations, laws, companies, human rights — all stories of the same kind.
Stories do something else: they let humans talk about what is not in front of them. "We'll hunt across the river tomorrow." "Suppose we had a tribe of our own." "There's better grassland beyond the mountain."
To speak of things that do not exist yet — or not yet happened — means humanity can rehearse in the head first: walk through it once in the story, then walk through it again in reality. The whole planning capacity of civilization, from city grids to five-year budgets, has its roots here.
One can say that the first piece of campfire gossip — about an absent prey animal, an event that had not yet occurred — was the first time humans left the present and entered the future.
This is the historical function of story: the only mechanism that has ever produced trust and cooperation among large groups of unrelated humans.
Story here is not "literature" and not "fiction." It is infrastructure — like roads and power grids, the load-bearing structure of a civilized society.
One footnote on the author's behalf: to say that money and nations are "stories" is not to say they are "hoaxes." A hoax is a lie with no shared basis; a story is consensus that hundreds of millions poured together over long centuries. The number on your banknote is abstract, but if everyone believes it, it buys concrete bread. Fictional — and effective.
II. Without Stories, People Lose Their Why
Stories create order, and they hand out "meaning" to each of us.
Harari notes a fundamental difference between humans and other animals: we don't merely want to live; we ask what we are living for. Stories used to answer that question: religion told you there was a heaven after death; the family told you carrying on the line was the point; the emperor told you loyalty and posthumous fame were the point.
In modernity, the old stories exited one by one. The divine narrative receded; the family narrative loosened; and a new story took their place: humanism — listen to your inner voice, follow your feelings, write the script of your own life.
In Homo Deus, Harari dissects this narrative's progression: people once asked "what does the priest think?", then "what does the organization think?", and now "what does my heart think?"
But that newer story is now under attack from two sides.
One side is AI. When algorithms know better than you which songs you'll like, whom you should marry, and whom you should vote for, "follow your heart" becomes a paradox — your heart was already raised on algorithmic feed. Harari warns: when authority migrates from "your feelings" to "big data," humanism — the story that underwrote the modern world for two or three hundred years — will exit the stage the way the religion it once replaced did.
Harari also names the next contender for that story: Dataism — a narrative that treats everything as data flows and ranks "the efficiency of processing data" as the highest good. In Dataism's eyes, your worth is roughly the worth of the data you contribute; when algorithms decide better than you do, the logic of efficiency gradually collects your decision-making authority. The danger of this story is that it doesn't even oppress you — it just makes "do what the algorithm says" look more efficient.
The other side is the vacuum of meaning. The old stories died; the new one hasn't arrived; and a whole generation shares a deflation. It is not an abstract concept — it has a concrete face: a generation of unprecedented material plenty that asks, as never before, what any of this is for; unprecedented choice, paired with unprecedented inability to decide. Old stories used to run the hard questions: religion told you why you needn't fear death; the family told you whom to spend your life with; the guild told you how your craft passed to your son. All those answers have been handed back to the individual, and the individual heart may not be strong enough to carry them.
Harari puts it this way: humans can endure hard lives, but they cannot endure lives without a sense of forward motion. On this I wholly agree.
A "sense of forward motion" is simply a story you believe: tomorrow will be better, effort will be rewarded, what I do matters.
Once that story collapses, material abundance only amplifies the emptiness. Modern people lack nothing except "why" — that is the spiritual blackout when the infrastructure called "story" goes down.
In my view, the heaviest insight in Harari's tetralogy is this: people live inside stories; when the stories collapse, people's sense of their own worth collapses with them.
From this, I extract two questions from his work — one about the individual, one about the species.
III. The Harari Micro Question: In a Social Transition, Will You Be the Carriage Driver Who Retrained, or the Horse Who Was Obsoleted?
This question concerns every ordinary person.
In 21 Lessons, Harari offers a parable: before the automobile, the horse carriage was civilization's circulatory system — drivers, horses, stables, and smithies sustained an entire industrial ecosystem. Then the car arrived. The driver could change trades: learn to drive, get a license, take fares — most of the skills in his hands would transfer. The horse? The horse could not change trades. The car did not need a more diligent horse. Industrial civilization's verdict on the species was wholesale: not the elimination of this or that horse, but the elimination of the function "horse" itself.
What he is really saying is not "be the successful driver or the obsolete horse," but: most people don't even have the driver option — you think you're the driver, but you're the horse.
Why could the driver retrain? On the surface, because he got a license. Deeper down, because he had hands that understood "driving" — feel, judgment, improvisation — things grown in the fingertips and nerves, which slid smoothly from the reins to the steering wheel. The horse was obsolete because its entire skill set was "pull a cart": nothing of it transferred.
Stories connect hearts; craft connects reality. The driver's position in the social network (driving a carriage) was granted by a story and can expire at any time; but the set of abilities in his hands for dealing with the real world is real, and the real never expires. The blacksmith will be unemployed, but "knowing the heat" won't; the accountant will be unemployed, but "a nose for numbers" won't; the driver will be unemployed, but "a feel for the system" won't.
Run this standard on your own job: how much of what you do today is "position" — the stuff that is void the moment you leave this platform, this post, this trade? And how much is "craft" — the stuff that can regrow in any new setting?
Three examples: a bookkeeper processing reports all day — the position is "keeping the books," the craft is "being ruthless with numbers and smelling when something's off"; the former AI does faster than any human, the latter needs a human to answer for it. A long-haul driver — the position is "gripping the wheel," the craft is "feel for machine, road, and weather"; the wheel will be taken over by autonomy, but the feel itself is an asset that transfers to other complex systems. A content editor — the position is "this account," the craft is "knowing what words make a tired person stop scrolling"; accounts change, this knowing doesn't date.
Real career planning in the AI age is not predicting which industry will survive — nobody can — but redeeming the craft hidden inside your position. Position is granted by stories; craft is yours.
So, the answer to the micro question: to become the driver who changes trades successfully, there is only one way — don't stake your identity on the position a story granted you; stake your craft on your contact with reality. Human embodied "feel" is exactly what today's AI lacks most.
Define yourself as the driver, and actively scout the road to your next trade — do not let yourself be consigned to the stable.
IV. The Harari Macro Question: What Story Can Humanity Steer By Today?
This question concerns the whole species.
Look back: humanity has been carried along by stories. Leaving Africa was a story — "what's beyond the savanna?" The Great Geographical Discoveries were a story — "the Orient lies at the end of the sea." The Enlightenment was a story — "reason can stand in for divine will." The moonshot was a story: "We choose to go to the Moon… not because it is easy, but because it is hard." — John F. Kennedy, 1962.
The essential work of a story is to make what has not yet happened worth striving for — ahead of time.
Humans are the only species that will bleed, save, and wait together for what has not yet happened. Without this story-making mechanism, humanity would forever be picking the fruit in front of it; no one would have sown the first seed of wheat.
And today? Scan the horizon: the human library of stories does not look healthy. Consumerism hardly qualifies as a story — it answers "what to buy," not "why live." Growth is half a story, but growth for what, no one can say. The greatest shared narrative deficit is this: humanity has acquired the power to destroy itself, but not yet a matching common story to constrain that power.
On Christmas Eve 1968, when Apollo 8 rounded the far side of the Moon and swung back into view, the astronauts photographed the blue Earth rising above the gray lunar horizon. The picture, known as Earthrise, caused a global sensation: it let billions of people see, for the first time, that all of us — every war, every ledger, every history — fit on one small planet. It was a story told on a single frame of film, and it advanced the environmental movement more effectively than any treaty. That is the power of a good story: it doesn't argue, it gives you a vantage point — and once you have the vantage point, the argument follows.
And today humanity's predicament is precisely this: we hold more lenses, compute, and channels of distribution than ever, and produce fewer and fewer Earthrise-class shared images — the supply of stories is short.
The prescription Harari offers at the end of Nexus: information networks must be built with a self-correcting mechanism — a society that tells stories and also gets them wrong must retain the capacity to discover error, admit error, and correct error.
The line the philosopher of science Karl Popper drew for science says the same thing: a theory is trustworthy not because it is told smoothly, but because it dares to state the conditions under which it could be refuted — falsifiability. A claim that can never be wrong is not a truth; it is a story refusing examination. Peer review, replication, and open data exist to institutionalize that correction. Science stands firm not because it tells the best-sounding story, but because it is the only story that writes "subject to correction" into its own rules. Yet correction can only keep humanity from falling; it cannot tell humanity where to set out.
This brings me again to "370,000 years ago," and "that upward gaze."
The story comes from Liu Cixin's science-fiction novella 《朝闻道》 (Chaowen Dao, "If I hear the Way in the morning"), which I quoted a few days ago in this column's "The Source Code of Civilization and the Three Great Tasks of Humankind." I'll quote it once more here.
"Humankind had built the largest particle accelerator in history, encircling the whole Earth — the 'Einstein Ring' — on the verge of witnessing the Grand Unified Model of the universe. On the day it was switched on, the accelerator vanished into thin air. Then an emissary of an alien higher civilization, calling himself 'the Preventer,' appeared and told the stunned Earth scientists: run at creation-level energies, the experiment would trigger vacuum decay and annihilate the universe. His duty was to put out the fire before the cosmos burned itself down.
The scientists asked the Preventer a question: since when have you been monitoring Earth? The Planck era? The Newtonian era? Surely not as far back as Aristotle? The Preventer's answer stunned everyone: 370,000 years ago. In the Fourth Ice Age, with the African continent under snow, several hominids hunched through the dark, hair awry; one of them tilted back his face to the sky, his pupils reflecting the distorted stars — and that primitive's gaze at the stars lasted past the alert threshold. He said: 'When life becomes aware that the universe holds mysteries, it is but one step from finally solving them. Earth's life took over four billion years to become aware of the universe's mysteries for the first time — yet that moment was less than 400,000 years from the completion of the Einstein Ring, and the most critical acceleration took less than 500 years. If that primitive's few minutes of gazing at the cosmos was his glimpse of a gemstone, then all of what you call human civilization is merely bending down to pick it up.'"
The question that primitive asked the stars was, logically: "What is that?" Over hundreds of thousands of years that question evolved — into telescopes, into spacecraft, into probes leaving the solar system…
Today, the "what is that" question remains, joined by a new one: "What else can we be?"
"What is that" is knowing the world; "what else can we be" is creating ourselves. The former asks what is out among the stars; the latter asks where humanity can go. The former ends in knowledge; the latter in survival. Humanity's living space has expanded from the ice fields of Africa to seven continents, from the ocean surface to the deep sea and low Earth orbit — and behind every expansion, a story of "what else can we be" was doing the pulling.
This story is not outdated today — it is more urgent: Earth, this cradle, should not be a permanent residence but a place of departure. In-situ use of extraterrestrial resources, asteroid mining, self-sustaining bases on the Moon and Mars — these are not science-fiction decoration; they are roads being built for the thought "what else can we be."
This is in no way an abandonment of the Earth — quite the opposite. Every technology required to extend our living space (closed-loop ecosystems, in-situ resource use, self-sufficiency in sealed systems) doubles, in reverse, into a tool for repairing the Earth; every step outward lightens the load on the planet beneath our feet. A cradle is not a cage; setting out is the best answer the cradle could hope for.
If this story needs a name, I would call it "posterity-ism" — it asks only for the smallest possible consensus: humanity must have a future, and those of us alive today owe a debt to those who come after.
This may be the most important lesson of "370,000 years of storytelling": the stories that can drive a human species are promises made to things that do not yet exist.
A thought seems weightless, yet it is the deepest foundation under civilization's load. The thought of 370,000 years ago was of no use to anyone: it kept out no wind, fed no belly, and fought off no enemy. But look back from now, and the whole of human civilization is nothing but the gem picked up from those few minutes of gazing.
Where humanity's longer journey leads will be decided by the thoughts of today.
